Bad Fads to Shelve in 2012
Posted by admin on February 21st, 2012
By Alexa Bosshardt, MPS, RD, LDN
This article presents five Bad Fad tendencies to avoid when starting in on those New Year’s Resolutions to exercise more and eat healthier, to lose weight, drink less, avoid white sugar and refined grains and Meat Lovers’ Pizzas and Buffalo Wings (with a delayed start on the last two until after the Super Bowl) and any other promises that are soon to be broken. This will be the first of 6 articles that will be posted every other month. Each Bad Fad will be explained in more detail in subsequent articles.
Bad Fad #1: Avoid any diet that encourages the consumption of an excessively high amount of stimulant ingredients. “Are you overweight? Do you want to lose 100 pounds in 8 months? Do you enjoy drinking 10 to 14 cans of Red Bull a day? Do you thrive on up to 1120 mg of caffeine daily?” This is how the intro to The Red Bull Diet begins. Need I go any further? Learn to recognize all the ingredients on a label that are sources of central nervous system or other stimulation to the body and understand your own body’s tolerance for stimulants.
Caffeine is considered a “legal” stimulant and has generally been proven to boost one’s mental energy level, as well as enhance physical output. Caffeine in the amount of 50-100 mg. (about what is contained in a good strong cup of coffee) is relatively safe for most as a mind and body booster; however, many “energy” products, as well as weight loss aids, can contain upwards of 200 mg. or more of caffeine, as well as other stimulants, such as Guarana, Yerba Mate, Hoodia Godonii Extract, Green Tea Extract, Bitter Orange/Ephedra and Ginsing. Excessive consumption of stimulants can cause nervousness, insomnia, gastric distress, increased blood pressure, an irregular heartbeat and, even, death. Go to www.energyfiend.com and click on “Death by Caffeine” to determine the amount of your favorite energy product, based on your weight, it takes to kill you. Nice…
Bad Fad #2: Avoid any diet that overemphasizes any of the three macronutrients. This includes high protein diets, which tend to continue in popularity in one form or another. Carbohydrate has always been and will continue to always be the brain and body’s preferred source of Calories for immediate and intense energy. In addition, plant foods provide fiber that animal foods do not. Fat calories and fat stores are also a vital source of energy that the body most effectively uses to sustain caloric needs during exercise of moderate intensity and longer duration. Mono and poly unsaturated oils from plant sources are heart healthy, as are fatty fish oils, which also provide positive cognitive support.
High quality dietary protein is important to make the proteins the body needs for growth, maintenance and repair of muscle tissue, as well as to perform so many other functions, including making hormones, some enzymes and antibodies and providing strength to hair and nails. Certain amino acids, particularly the branched chain amino acids, play an important role in muscle recovery after exercise. However, most Americans, including athletes, can easily meet their body’s protein needs without sacrificing the body’s need for carbohydrate. In addition, many athletes tend to over-supplement with protein-based powders and bars, thinking they need much more protein than they really do. Protein needs are based on a “grams of protein per kg.of body weight” formula and, also, as “protein Calories as a percent of total Calories consumed”
Bad Fad #3: Avoid any diet that is “hypo caloric”. As the name suggests, a “hypo caloric” diet refers to any diet that is too low in Calories to support a person’s basal metabolic needs (BMR or “basal metabolic rate”). An individual’s BMR is dependent on many factors, including, height, weight, gender, body fat % and age and reflects the body’s caloric needs when the body is at rest. For a sedentary individual, this may represent about 2/3 of daily Calorie needs. Other factors, most importantly exercise, can significantly increase the body’s total caloric needs. Hypo caloric diets may restrict intake to as few as 400-500 Calories per day and include liquid “elimination” or “cleansing diets”, such as the Lemonade Diet and the Hollywood Juice Diet. The HCG Diet, the focus of numerous recent filings by the FTC and FDA, is both hypo caloric and applies “magical” properties to the use of HCG. (www.fda.gov/hcgdiet) . Which leads us to Bad Fad #4:
Bad Fad #4: Avoid any diet that assigns mystical and magical fat-burning properties to any one food or drink, such as The Cabbage Soup Diet, The Chicken Soup Diet, The Grapefruit Diet, or The Cookie Diet. No single food is a nutritionally complete food and no single food has special fat-burning properties. If this were true, do you think over 2/3 of the people in this country would still be overweight or obese? Just saying…
Bad Fad #5: Avoid any diet that is based on theories of “conscious combining”. The Grandma of these types of diets, The Beverly Hills Diet, was first published in 1981 and contains useless and unproven diet advice such as every day must start with fruit and only fruit and once another food is eaten that day no more fruit can be eaten for the rest of that day. The premise of the diet is that eating one type of food with another (a protein with a carbohydrate, for example) destroys digestive enzymes and causes weight gain and poor digestion. Really? The Cabbage Soup Diet crosses into this “conscious combining” territory, as well, with such nonsense as allowing bananas only on Day 4 and no baked potatoes on Days 3 and 6. These diets make dieters feel as if they will fail to lose weight if they deviate from the very strict guidelines of the daily meal plans and completely muddles the way the body physiologically reacts to food.
Stay tuned for upcoming articles that will address each of these “Bad Fads” and more! In the meantime, “Eat well, Be Well!”
Alexa Bosshardt is a Registered/Licensed Dietitian, a professionally trained chef and an avid cyclist. FitCulinary, LLC is a company dedicated to providing nutrition support and developing recipes and new products for restaurant companies and food manufacturers.
